[Pharmwaste] Article on flame retardants from Phila. Inquirer of Sept. 8, 2008

[Thompson.Virginia at epamail.epa.gov]

Posted on Mon, Sep. 8, 2008

Certain flame retardants may make us sick


By Sandy Bauers


Inquirer Staff Writer


A common group of flame retardants used since the 1970s and credited
with saving lives is proving to be a pervasive contaminant in the
environment that may be harmful to human health.


> The chemicals were added to textiles, couches, carpet pads,
mattresses, and the hard plastics in TVs, computers, and other
electronic devices.


> Known as PBDEs, these organic compounds are now widespread in humans
and the environment. They have been detected in breast milk and human
blood, including umbilical-cord blood and livers of fetuses.


> Health studies suggest that they may, at high levels of exposure,
cause cancer.


> Within the last year, studies have also found undescended testicles in
babies whose mothers had high levels of PBDEs, decreased sperm quality
in men, and effects on thyroid function.


> The data are "young" and not definitive, said Linda Birnbaum, a senior
Environmental Protection Agency toxicologist, who has studied the
chemicals for several years. "But it is concerning."


> PBDEs have been found in wildlife around the planet - from seals in
the Arctic to eels in the Delaware River and bluefish caught off the
coast of New Jersey.


> Canada, Europe, and about a dozen states - but not Pennsylvania or New
Jersey - have taken action to limit or ban the most common variations of
the chemicals.


> Ikea began phasing out the chemicals in 1998 and since 2002 has sold
no furniture containing them.


> In response to bans elsewhere, in 2004 U.S. manufacturers voluntarily
ceased production of the version most often used in home furniture.


> But researchers worry that older furniture or carpeting is still in
use and may even be in some stores.


> These products "have long lives in our homes," said Heather Stapleton,
a Duke University environmental chemistry professor and PBDE expert.


> Worse, consumers can't tell what kind of flame retardant the products
they are buying contain. "No one is required to list" them, Stapleton
said.


> The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has begun monitoring
levels in humans as part of its National Health and Nutrition
Examination Survey.


> An EPA panel's latest status report, in March, showed it was
continuing to assess risks and evaluate substitutes. It also is
requiring manufacturers "to develop test data that will provide a better
understanding of its fate in the environment," a spokeswoman said.


> But the agency drew harsh criticism this year for dismissing Deborah
Rice, the toxicologist who chaired the panel. An industry lobbyist had
complained that she was biased. Critics called it another case of the
agency caving in to business. The Inspector General's Office is
investigating.


> Industry spokesman John Kyte defended the chemicals as "very
efficient, very effective flame retardants." He said well-financed
activists with Internet savvy had unfairly "targeted" PBDEs - or
polybrominated diphenyl ethers.


> What complicates matters is that PBDEs, which are one group of
brominated flame retardants, have 209 possible versions.


> Concern has focused on two commercial variations, penta and deca,
Latin words reflecting their atomic structures.


> Penta was the type used in furniture, mainly in polyurethane foam
common in mattresses, carpet pads and upholstery. In 2004, it was banned
in Europe, and the sole U.S. manufacturer voluntarily withdrew it from
the market. Ten states have also banned it.


> The second form, deca, is still widely used in hard-plastic casings
for televisions and other electronic equipment, even though many makers
- including Apple, Dell and Hewlett-Packard - have decided to use
alternatives.


> Last year, both Washington state and Maine passed bills to phase out
deca. This year, court action in Europe resulted in a ban, and Canada
banned its production.


> Deca is proving to have multiple lives.


> Swedish researcher Ake Bergman, who several years ago termed PBDEs a
"ticking time bomb," is alarmed to see deca making a reappearance in
products that use recycled plastics.


> Opponents want the industry to use substitutes for deca. "It's not
that there aren't alternatives," industry spokesman Kyte said. "The
sticky point is the alternatives have not been as well-tested and
analyzed and don't have the track record of deca. Are we trading one
perceived problem for something different?"


> When researchers started measuring PBDEs in humans in the United
States, they were amazed to find levels significantly higher than those
in Europe. They concluded it probably had something to do with stricter
flammability standards in this country.


> Eventually they found the chemicals in household dust, which suggested
an avenue of exposure. People get it on their hands, and put parts of
their hands in their mouths.


> To test the hypothesis, EPA researchers studied house cats, which sit
on carpets and sofas and are continually grooming themselves. Sure
enough, the cats had levels 10 times that of humans.


> That put the focus on children, who also crawl on carpeting and put
their hands in their mouths.


> Another avenue for exposure is a car on a hot day. PBDEs have been
used in seats and interior plastics.


> Other potential problems: Although PBDEs are flame retardants,
eventually they will burn. When they do, they could generate toxic
vapors.


> Meanwhile, researchers are discovering, to their chagrin, that PBDEs
are ubiquitous in nature.


> They have been found in California peregrine falcons, Puget Sound orca
whales, and Greenland sled dogs. Among 33 species of Hudson River fish,
PBDEs were found in 98.4 percent of the samples.


> PBDEs have even shown up among invertebrates near Antarctica's McMurdo
outfall, at levels near those in urbanized areas of North America.


> Researchers surmised it was the result not of long-distance transport,
but furnishings and electronics at research bases.


> In the chemical's pervasiveness and persistence, researchers see
disquieting parallels to lead in house paint and to PCBs -
polychlorinated biphenyls - industrial chemicals banned 30 years ago but
still common in the environment.


> Similarly, with PBDEs, "we're looking at a very problematic chemical,"
said Bill Walker, vice president of the Environmental Working Group, an
advocacy organization that wants them banned.


> The group's work has concentrated on testing small samples of the
human population to provide snapshots pointing to the need for further
study. For instance, they obtained archived Red Cross samples of
umbilical cord blood from 10 newborns, and tests showed PBDEs in every
one of them.


> On Thursday, the organization released the results of a study of 20
children, showing levels in their blood were triple those of their
mothers.


> In July, a new report on the health of the Delaware Estuary
highlighted research funded by the estuary program, Pennsylvania Sea
Grant, and the Academy of Natural Sciences that is just beginning to
document PBDEs in the estuary.


> Researcher Jeffrey Ashley, a Philadelphia University chemistry
professor, figured that if PBDEs were present, they would surely show up
in eels, which have fatty tissue where the chemicals would accumulate.


> Looking at samples of 18 eels from six locations, PBDEs were in every
one. Further, comparing PBDE levels to those found in other fish, "these
were some of the highest."


> Now, Ashley and colleagues are studying aquatic species at the John
Heinz National Wildlife Refuge at Tinicum to map how the chemical
accumulates as it moves up the food chain.


> The marsh is where Delaware River fish are breeding and eating, and
PBDEs are likely high. "When it rains, you can see the plastic bottles
and condoms," he said. "What you can't see is the flush of
contaminants."


>


Contact staff writer Sandy Bauers at 215-854-5147 or
sbauers at phillynews.com.
                                                                         
                                                                         
                                                                         
 (Embedded image moved to file: pic25052.gif)                            
                                                                         
                                                                         
                                                                         
                                                                         
                                                                         

                                                                         
                                                                         
                                                                         
 Find this article at:                                                   
 http://www.philly.com/philly/news/homepage/20080908_Certain_flame_retar 
 dants_may_make_us_sick.html?adString=ph.news/homepage;!category=homepag 
 e;&randomOrd=091208095110&viewAll=y&c=y                                 
                                                                         




Virginia Thompson
Sustainable Healthcare Sector Coordinator
Office of Environmental Innovation (3EA40)
US Environmental Protection Agency Region 3
1650 Arch Street, Philadelphia, PA  19103
Voice:  (215) 814-5755; Fax (215) 814-2783
thompson.virginia at epa.gov
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: pic25052.gif
Type: image/gif
Size: 43 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://lists.dep.state.fl.us/pipermail/pharmwaste/attachments/20080915/8a2e74ac/pic25052.gif